GutGuesserPlay today's challenge

Why the average misleads (and what to use instead)

When a few values are huge, the average stops meaning what it seems to. The median and the geometric mean, explained without formulas.

Walk into a bar with ten people earning ordinary salaries. Their average income is an ordinary salary. Now a billionaire walks in. The average shoots up so far that, according to it, everyone in the bar is rich. Nobody's pay has changed, but the average no longer describes anyone in the room.

The average gets dragged around

The ordinary average, adding up and dividing, works very well when the values are similar: people's heights, a month's temperatures, a class's marks. But when a few values are far bigger than the rest, those few call the shots. A lot of real-world things work exactly like that: incomes, city sizes, website visits, earthquakes. A few giant cases and a crowd of small ones.

The median: whoever's in the middle

The median is the value right in the middle when you sort all the data from smallest to largest. If there are eleven people in the bar, the median is what the sixth earns. The billionaire moves it one place at most: it's still an ordinary salary. That's why serious statistics on income or house prices almost always report the median rather than the mean.

It's also why, when you pool many people's estimates to tap the wisdom of crowds, you use the median. One person typing three extra zeros is enough to send the average into orbit; the median doesn't even notice.

The geometric mean: the middle in multiples

There's a third average, less well known and very handy for estimating. If you're torn between 10 and 1,000, the ordinary average would say about 500. But 500 is fifty times more than 10 and only twice less than 1,000: it's heavily lopsided. The geometric mean looks for the point that's the same number of times away from both ends: 100, which is ten times 10 and a tenth of 1,000.

You calculate it by multiplying the two values and taking the square root, but you don't need to: just count zeros. Between 10 (one zero) and 1,000 (three zeros), the middle has two zeros. Between 1,000 and 100,000, the middle is 10,000. When you're unsure by just one order of magnitude, the middle is about a third of the way along: between 100 and 1,000, a bit over 300.

When to use which

And in GutGuesser

The cloud of answers you see after locking in is drawn on a ruler in multiples, so the middle of the cloud you see by eye is already a geometric middle. That's why crowds do better than you'd think from looking at answers one by one: wild guesses too high and too low weigh the same and cancel out.

Want to try it?

Four questions a day, one minute. Nobody knows the number; whoever gets closest wins.

Play today's challenge